Twelve Questions from Reddit

I recently participated in an AMA – Ask Me Anything on the Reddit Futurology subgroup. Here’s a selection of questions and answers from this session.

twelve-questionsWhat do you find that has changed in the past ten years that is leaning towards your own fictional work?

The trend toward transparency being crucial to our survival and freedom has been in my fiction and nonfiction for decades and it is coming true. Last year, largely unheralded by media, saw the most important civil liberties decision in thirty years, when the courts and the Obama Administration separately declared it to be “settled law” that citizens have a right to record their interactions with police, in public places. Of course there will be tussles over the details for years. I’ll talk later about how we must also watch the watchers of the watchers.

What, if anything, have you changed your mind about in the last 12 months?

In politics — I reluctantly concluded that reason will not prevail and the U.S. is doomed to a new phase of its 200 year Civil War. In science — I learned that we can look beyond the “curtain” of light that raised 325,000 years after the Big Bang! In literature, I learned that a new novelist in China – Liu Cixin – has leaped ahead by a couple of generations and will stun western readers, in the fall.  Hey, I am surprised a whole lot!

What do you believe (if anything) is necessary for our society and culture to change, in order to prevent a collapse/new dark age/extinction of our race? Or – if nothing – why?

UnlikelinessPositiveSumSocietyI’ve pushed for 30 years what I think is the secret of the Western Enlightenment Experiment — The Positive Sum Game. Jared Diamond in Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed shows what will happen if Earth is run by the Zero Sum thinking that dominated in 99% of human societies.

We get positive sum outcomes out of science, democracy, markets etc because they are competitive! But it is REGULATED competition that minimizes blood and cheating and maximizes folks leveraging against each others creativity.

The mistake of the left is to badmouth competition, when Adam Smith was the first liberal!

The mistake of the right is to imagine we can get these benefits without very meticulous regulation to prevent cheating, which ruined 99% of human societies and made them zero (or negative) sum. And it is winners and the strong who inevitably try to cheat. Look at how regulated sports is! It would collapse otherwise.

Right now oligarchs are trying to turn our society zero sum and feudal again. The attempt happens every generation. If we can prevent it and restore a pragmatic, can-do society, maximizing the flat-open-transparent arena of joyful-fair competition, then we may reach Star Trek.

Which self-preventing prophecy do you think would have the largest positive impact the on future if published today?

self-preventing-prophecyIn my essay, The Self-Preventing Prophecy: How a Dose of Nightmare Can Tame Tomorrow’s Perils, I talk about how the highest form of Science Fiction is a predictive novel that scares millions into fighting against the portrayed future. e.g. Soylent Green or Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451. The greatest Self-Preventing Prophecy was Orwell’s 1984, which I discuss here.

A related topic is why so many recent films and novels wallow in dystopias that are NOT “self-preventing” because their scenarios are lazy and stupid, as I discuss in The Idiot Plot.

Today? I’d warn about collapse of confidence in our creative-pragmatic can-do civilization. The worst problem we have is so many of our neighbors turning stylishly cynical.  Too many of YOU think you invented “brave cynicism” when it is a drug-addict cop-out.


==On the Singularity==

What’s your opinion on the possibility of humanity forming a collective consciousness through the internet?

I portray this happening in Earth and in Foundation’s Triumph. The latter was in Isaac Asimov’s universe so it portrayed a Gaia/Galaxia uber mind that essentially takes over. Nicer than the Borg because folks don’t clank and whirr but instead float and go ‘om’ and commune…

I do think that to be a simplistic type of Overmind (see Arthur C. Clarke’s Childhood’s End, too.) That is not how complexity actually layers, in complex systems lilt nature. In Earth I portray individual humans retaining all of their individuality, with the higher shared consciousness riding lightly above, benefiting from human individuality and eccentricity, absorbing and digesting their input the way you ponder the countless fleeting thoughts in your own head.  It is a more complex and subtle kind of “over mind.”  It might be a positive-sum win-win.

dowereallywantimmortalityDo you believe biological immortality could happen in 10 – 25 years from now? Also what do you want to see in the future with new technologies coming out?

I deem it pretty unlikely. I am a bit of a grouch-curmugeon in the transhumanist-life-extension community. Humans are already the Methuselahs of mammals, getting three times as many heartbeats as mice and elephants. We have probably plucked the low-hanging longevity fruit and the next steps will be very hard.

What I do expect to see is methods of brain/skull preservation that are far cheaper and more convenient than cryonics. Plasticization etc. No revival, of course and most intra-cellular info would be lost. But the location of a trillion synapses might be preserved and serve as boundary conditions for a fairly good emulation program that could upload a version of you, someday. Is that good enough? Depends.

See my larger essay: Do We Really Want Immortality?

Where do you differ with Ray Kurtzweil on the singularity?

KurzweilSingularityCoverRay and I get along, but I am a contrarian. Among those who do not believe in change – alas many of our fellow citizens – I speak about how rapidly human destiny is being challenged with new powers. Around Ray? I am cautionary.

For example, Kurzweil believes Moore’s Law, all by itself, will make him immortal by creating Soulful machines who will gladly incorporate us and human values in the adventure of super-life. I portray this happening! In Earth and in Existence! But at Ray’s conferences, I splash cold water.

He calculates Moore’s Law by crossing the rate of transistor growth in machines with number of synapses in a human brain… about a trillion. But synapses may just be the tip of the iceberg, especially if there’s intracellular computing! If so, Moore’s Law will need maybe TEN more doublings!

Which do you think we’ll reach first? Relatively cheap spaceflight, or full body ‘virtual reality’ simulations? The latter can, of course, include MMI equivalents instead of external bodysuits.

Sure VR will be the main thing for most of us. If we could make cheap “deputies” we could send them to Mars and bring back the heads and “live” the experience!  Say, I offer that in Kiln People!

 ==On Books…and Aliens==

temptationI just want to say that I really enjoyed your Uplift books. Do you have any plans for new books?

Indeed I am currently working to get Creideiki and Orley off that planet, at last! The Brightness Reef trilogy settles the fate/destiny of the ship Streaker, and a lot else. Till then, see the story “Temptation” downloadable from my website. Some will argue that Existence is uplift!

What do you make of Cliford D. Simak’s dog and animal society in City? I allways found his ideas on animal and foreign intelligence interesting, if somewhat anchored to his time.

Yes, Simak influenced me. Also the fact that I have never had a novel that did not feature an ape or other primate! 😉

Have you looked into the topic of UFOs and if so, do you have a stance on the UFO phenomenon?

Sorry but this “phenomenon” is taking care of itself. Brin’s Corollary to Moore’s Law (yes it’s called that) is that CAMERAS get faster, cheaper, more numerous and mobile at a rate much faster than Moore’s Law.

thoseeyesThis means that the excuses for blurry UFO images get slimmer and slimmer. Have you done the math? All of the places where a UFO was dimly blurry in the distance 20 years ago… would have dozens of folks with cell cams right below it today! Please do the math. If images remain blurry, it is because they are teasing us and staying just out of range, even taking Brin’s Corollary and the lens quality of iPhones into account!

In that case, they are bastards. Snub em.

Please… you know I am interested in aliens! I spend my life on the topic, in SETI and in fiction. I’ll even admit a very slim chance there might be UFOs! But I find the creatures described in these stories to be illogical, immoral, unimaginative, ridiculous and WAY down on my list of priorities.

==On Privacy==

What is your idea on a transparent society, and how does that affect personal privacy? Or should we start getting used to having no privacy?

privacy-doomedThe most common assumption of people who have not read my articles or The Transparent Society is that – as “Mr. Transparency” I oppose privacy or think it is doomed.

No way! A free people will want and demand some privacy! In Chapter 4 of The Transparent Society I discuss how essential some core privacy will be… though it will be closer and narrower.

But the irony is that we will only have that core if we live in a world that is mostly open, in which most people know most of what’s going on, most of the time. Only then will voyeurs and spies and sneaks be deterred, because they’ll get caught!

There is so much to this. See more articles about transparency, freedom and technology.




Filed under science

23 responses to “Twelve Questions from Reddit

  1. There are a few people who still choose to use the laptop, employing the end, using a
    touchpad to scroll by multiple windows 7 is irritating Either this or they will milk a person with your revenue through
    high interest rates or a really huge pay in To be eligible
    for cash loans Canada, documents to assist that the mortgage loan seekers
    gain no less than $1,1,000 in every month are also being produced It will be possible find
    the placing of the lenders easily as a result of internet I desired to start shelling out my financial products despite the fact that I could truthfully file for deferment; Nevertheless, I put to use trying to store the $200 per month for my obligations and it appeared
    to be impossible Once a us takes that will
    first employment flipping cheese burgers
    as a youngster, he commences a continuous cycle involving
    owing funds to the Government that proceeds until the day he is disapated, and
    sometimes outside of Because of the insurance plans of equality promoted by numerous Democrats and contrary primarily by a lot of white Southern Democrats, correction occurred Many unpredicted cash
    problems can easily be satisfied without any financial institutions constraints for instance: Nonetheless it solves this unseen fiscal crunches from
    the non-home owners and also poor credit members Stability associated
    with employment is really a different desire for eligibility Some individuals think
    that somebody who is item will be organic (and may “turn into dirt”) it is really alright in order to throw the item anywhere
    These include: everlasting residency connected with UK,
    previously 18 yoa, a valid profile of lender and a long-lasting source of
    income that provides monthly earnings of not less than It
    also received its advantages, like infinite mailing resources I could make use of for myself It’s
    typical to generally be required to present your recent and present handles, your home plus work numbers, your career
    information as well as length of time you have been employed,
    a person’s banking info such as checking out and bank account information, and
    many of these apps have a portion for facts related to any credit cards you might have After conducting the verification of the
    work and banking accounts details made available from you,
    cash will be transmitted directly into your account You will find a monthly payment strategy
    that will suit your lifestyle and invite you to pay off
    the debt anyone already have The following California-based
    company continues to be notorious around bullying
    and also intimidation ways to getting individuals to pay about debts that they’ve settled and also no
    longer are obligated to pay on Knowing how to discover the value of
    an organization is easier than you might think A few products
    are a new neat originality such as — Egg Ice
    cubes – and can even be a enjoyable surprise
    for the neighborhood use a picnic Although don’t go out paying
    for the card so that you know sure that you are able to pay the
    money back prior to higher Apr interest rates kicks in, because you will end up repaying the same interst
    seeing that before Monthly wages of the debtor and an effective bank account are two criteria to
    help avail the following loan

  2. Hi, ӏ log on to your new stuff daily. Your writng style
    is awesome, keep ɗoing what you’re doing!

  3. Michael claims that he is proud that Farrah may have finally found her calling and
    says that it isn’t what you do butt how you do it. They feel celebrities, fueled with a
    sense of entitlement that can come with super stardom and its riches, just do what they want.
    She agreed to meet Paul at his apartment where the couple had once lived together.

  4. For example, A-class company will be preferred over B-rated company.
    t mean that you have to go to the first salvage yard you will come
    across in the Yellow Pages. Some BMW salvage cars
    are intended for busy car rebuilders.

  5. He can then offer you the options that are available to you.
    Care is taken so that even medical care for bruise is also
    taken care of. The lawyers of the Chicago
    are professional and aggressive in their profession and
    they want to investigate the case thoroughly for their clients.

  6. In short, if you want to make money online by blogging, Word – Press will help you
    in spending less time in managing your blog
    and you have more time in making money. Keep them even if you don’t use them as other players fill surely find them useful.
    However, if you put in the effort, you will reap
    your rewards.

  7. Interior to several of the world’s most beautiful
    beaches, Ipanema and Copacabana come to mind, the Sugar Loaf Mountains,
    the Corcovado and Christ the Redeemer, Rio de Janeiro is certainly
    one of the most best-selling tourist destinations in the world.
    You are so excited you get thousands of mailers made and mail them out only to get no response.
    Often times schools are lacking funding, or a playground is
    in need or repair, if parenting groups take the matter seriously
    and demand change, chances are things will happen quickly.

  8. Another interesting relationship that the report has proven, is that the locations
    of the claims management companies who sell on cases in the form of
    referrals to selected solicitors, had the highest number of claims.
    It is critical that they collaborate with their Chicago personal injury attorney every single
    step of the way to guarantee they receive the justice and the settlement they ought to get.

    Google Glass is also a great tool to remain connected to the clients on the go.

  9. So, if you are having a similar difficulty due
    to an auto accident in Daytona Beach, you must hire the best, skilled and
    experienced Daytona Beach auto accident lawyer to be benefited.
    You will find it vital to find an attorney that practices exclusively in auto accidents.
    The pros are promising to anyone who is looking to make additional income just from
    talking to friends and family, but before you run out to start
    selling pre-paid legal services to your friends and family you should be aware of the cons

  10. I can’t say that I even noticed the music at all, and that is mainly because you
    have to focus 100% on the driving and most everything else falls by the
    wayside. I have a friend who is also playing and it shows me his best score on each event.
    The field of professional selling has changed dramatically since World War II.

  11. Thank you a bunch for sharing this with all folks you really realize what you are talking about!

    Bookmarked. Kindly also discuss with my website =).
    We may have a hyperlink change contract among us

  12. Hi there, its fastidious paragraph about media print, we all know media is a enormous
    source of data.

  13. Sսperbe pοst : continue comm ça

  14. Jе peuх vous dire quе c’est constamment du plaisir de passer sur ce site internet

  15. It’s actually a great and useful piece of info.

    I’m glad that you simply shared this helpful information with us.
    Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.

  16. Вon, je n’ai guère fini de lire par contre je reviendrai dans
    la soirée

  17. • Three simple steps that will help you determine the best dimensions for the
    backyard patio. Fix it: Keep up with routine maintenance and it won’t bury you when you are getting a house ready to sell.
    This is particularly useful if your backyard is not fenced in.

  18. The Story: In 1972 a tiny team of investors and an inventor with a terrific suggestion purchased an abandoned Milk
    Queen in Roswell, New Mexico as well as began generating just what became the world
    criterion for escalator passenger protection devices.
    The Tale: Movement Industries is North America’s leader for MRO (maintenance, repair service
    as well as operations) industrial substitute components as
    well as services. Our Component in the Tale: We established the co-op program’s message Brand names You Trust, Individuals You Depend on to raise Motion Industries’
    position as the full bundle” in commercial production supply.

  19. From weight loss, disease prevention, cures of a-topical
    skin disease tto saving mony and the environment, you can experience iit all by drinking alkaline
    ionized water. Everyone knows that water is an essential part of a hwalthy life.
    Many people are concerned that this is beikng brilliantly designed too monopolize the public water supply.
    Furthermore, ionmized water does not rid the supply
    of the essential minerals that all humans require for optimum health.
    It purifies and enhyances domestic water in a two-step process.

    For this reason, many people aree ionizing their water in order to experience and enjoy
    its health benefits by using one of the numerous water ionizer units that are
    now aavailable today as a result of the latest technological advancements in the present world.

  20. You wont find Adiphene in your native pharmacy or
    some huge store like Walmart or Walgreens.

    Perhaps the main reason behind this though is that you have developed
    a dependence on food. Assuming that you aren’t a super-taught individual, you will have
    some major snags adding on control over your zealous urges
    towards consuming distinctive sustenances.

  21. Aby otrzymać debet w banku musimy przeznaczyć dużo swojego
    czasu by załatwić wszystkie potrzebne pliki oraz poręczycieli.

  22. More than 60 of our specialists are previous U.S.
    patent inspectors, many with experience in industrial-related industries such as transmissions, robotics,
    textile manufacturing devices, building shutoff, devices and also pump
    settings up, weaponries, oil well drilling devices,
    and also different sorts of engine systems In high-stakes
    instances including complex issues, our experts rely on their technological
    and lawful backgrounds to supply idea and also advice to clients
    on concerns that have important legal and company ramifications.

  23. I have to thank you for the efforts you’ve put in penning this blog.
    I’m hoping to check out the same high-grade blog posts from you later on as well.
    In truth, your creative writing abilities has motivated me to get my very own website now 😉

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s